Thursday, 7 February 2013

Weekly Reflection: "Deaf by Design"

On February 6th, 2013, Mr. Chung presented to us an article called "Deaf by Design" together with a video called "Sound and Fury".  After questioning every assumption a hearing person would make of the Deaf, the article and video challenged the viewers to come to some conclusions, so here are mine. 

Q1: Is it more of a blessing or a curse to have the ability to alter our genetic codes?
A1: First of all, I don't think we are altering our genetic codes so much as manipulating them. Now, if asked if this is more of a blessing or a curse...I would say it is more of a blessing because it gives us the choice to make better what we could do absolutely nothing about in the past. Key word: choice. If someone believes that designing a baby to suit specific needs is wrong and unnatural, that is up to them. But with the ability to manipulate genes, others now have the ability to satisfy those needs when before they had no options. It is a curse as well, though, because now we must decide what is ethical and acceptable, and what is not--what is proper and what is misuse. 

Q2: Do the deafs have as much right as the rest of us to abort a fetus that is, in their view, disabled?
A2: Should anyone abort a fetus they believe to be disabled? In some ways, I can understand why people might not want a "disabled" baby--a severe handicap might never allow their child to have a fulfilling life, so never being born could be justified as the more humane option. But for a deaf couple would it be more humane to abort a hearing baby? I don't think this is true. There would definitely be a gap between baby and parents if the child was born, but this in my opinion doesn't justify not allowing a hearing baby to live. I don't think it's enough of an issue. This goes both ways: I don't think it's right for hearing parents to want to abort a deaf fetus. Only in more extreme circumstances would aborting a disabled fetus be justified. 

Q3: Is "disability" a relative term? What constitutes a person's disability? 
A3; Disability is definitely a relative term. Mr. Chung's example of a really annoying ongoing noise would turn a deaf person's "disability" into an advantage. Also, how much of an impediment is a disability? Everyone has something that holds them back compared to everyone else: for example, bad eyesight, a fear of public speaking or even an allergy like me. In many ways every one of us is disabled. We can't be so narrow-minded as to impose what is "normal" for the majority of people onto everybody without considering that these so-called "disabilities" have their own bright sides. 

Q4: Is it Heather's best interest to be raised as the only hearing child in the family?
A4: In Heather's case, it is in her best interest to receive complete support from her family, and being the only hearing child would negatively impact her family life. Her father especially feels very strongly about Deaf culture and said in the video he felt like Heather's wish to hear insulted him and his way of life. Heather needs her father to be supportive of her. Also, if one thinks of her future, being deaf is now less of a disadvantage than ever. There are now so many other ways of communicating other than talking that I'm sure the very bright Heather would capitalize on. 


No comments:

Post a Comment