Thursday, 14 March 2013

From Stem to Roots: Reflection on "Fast and Furious"

The article "Fast and Furious" dealt with induced pluripotent stem cells (iPS cells), and their possibilities, difficulties and future. But first we must deal with the roots of the issues surrounding iPS cells. 


Q1: Discuss the significance of iPS cells in stem cell research. Do you believe it would be better to replace embryonic stem cells with iPS cells despite the success embryonic stem cells already have? What are the advantages and disadvantages?
A1: I think iPS cells are very significant, and their concept is pretty revolutionary. It was creative to realize that we were making assumptions with the belief that cell specialization is an irreversible one-way process, and the only way to get unspecialized cells is to harvest them at the embryo stage. iPS cells show that we cannot assume anything in nature, and that it may be possible (in fact it is possible!) to take a specialized cell and go "back in time" to induce pluripotency. So I'm really impressed with this kind of thinking, and to me, this kind of thinking alone is very significant in scientific research. If we can get more people to question and think like this, we will probably find potentially very simple answers to complicated problems. 
     But specifically for iPS cells, I think that they are very significant because they are personalized to suit someone's individual needs. They can be taken from any person and perhaps even any body part, and used to create whatever tissue is needed. This makes iPS cells safer to use than embryonic stem cells, and maybe even cheaper, since they are sourced from your own body. If this kind of technology can be perfected, it would be very powerful. Also, it does not deal with the same ethical issues that embryonic stem cells deal with, because it does not deal with an embryo. I think this would lead to more support overall for the possibility of iPS cells. I think, given time, iPS cell technology could be on par with embryonic stem cell technology, with the added benefits mentioned above. Even if for now embryonic stem cells are safer, it is only because they have had many more years of research behind them. Once iPS cells reach that level of research, I think it will be the preference. 


Q2: What problems do you think could occur with the usage of iPS cells? How do you think we could solve these problems?
A2: I think there could be many technical problems associated with iPS cells. For example, there is a fine line between letting the iPS cells grow enough to regenerate whatever they are supposed to, but also not grow enough that they might cause instead of cure cancer. Also, one of the essential ingredients to making cells pluripotent again, c-Myc, increases the likelihood of developing cancer. There are additional issues such as whether "reprogramming might shove cells so far from what is physiologically normal that they become pathological." However, I think that with any new and potentially useful technology, there are also potential dangers. Hopefully through continued research and studies, ways around these issues will be found. 
     Although I think this is a long shot, a possible problem might be people who do not take care of their bodies because it is so easy to get personalized, specialized cells to replace whatever damage they have done. For instance, people may not bother to exercise or eat right because they can easily replace their coronary arteries or kidney using iPS cells. iPS cells might not pose as much as guilt as embryonic stem cells would, so people would not have as much qualms for using them. But I don't know if this will be an issue unless the price of iPS cells becomes very low. I'm pretty sure that although iPS cell technology would be accessible, it wouldn't be cheap enough to allow for misuse of the technology. For the most part, I feel that iPS cells, like any stem cell, would give hope to people who have diseases or conditions that cannot be treated other than by the replacement of their cells. iPS cells would be a great tool for regenerative medicine, which to me is basically good. 

Wednesday, 13 March 2013

Valley Fold or Mountain Fold? Reflection on DNA Origami

Q: Discuss the possibility of making an entire human being with the technology we have today? What do you think of it? Would you be able to accept an entirely synthesized human? What are the consequences? Do you think science has a limit?

A: Just like origami, the future of gene research is based on the decisions and steps that we take now. But do we really want the end product that we are heading towards?


Admittedly, making an entire human being using the technologies described in the "DNA Origami" article and through other technologies like 3D printing is a long way off. For now we may be able to make individual parts or print organs such as bladders, but making an entire human is quite different. Not only do we have to make this individual parts or organs, but we have to make them come together, make them integrate in a way that will allow them to function. And this is a great challenge. Even though we know a lot about the human body, there are probably millions of ways that our organs and cells rely on each other in order to carry out their duties, connections that we never dreamed of. How will we connect all these things together well enough to synthesize a whole person? 


Maybe we won't need to understand it all, though. I think sometimes these great leaps in science happen with scientists working sort of blindly, not really sure what they are doing but hoping that it might work, and if it does, not really knowing what happened. If we do ever synthesize a human, I think this might be the case, because I don't see how we could ever understand the human body so completely as to connect its parts to make a living organism. 


Which is another aspect of creating a human: do we really want to create life? Personally, I wouldn't want to. I don't think it is right or ethical. Think about how this manmade person would function in society. I feel that even if we tried hard to accept this person socially, we could not help but treat them as inferior to those who were "naturally" made. In fact, we find it hard to accept people who are different even when they are "naturally" made. How much more will we find it difficult to accept someone with a difference as fundamental as this, someone who was not even born?


Why do we need even need to make people in this way? Logistically, our planet already struggles with the issue of overpopulation. It is one thing to make organs or body parts to improve quality of life for those who are already alive but another to selfishly make an entire living person (as we all know from The Island). I don't see the point in creating life. Exploring life has the possibility to benefit people through your discoveries, but creating it is, to me, sort of megalomaniacal. As well, it degrades the life we already have: it makes it seem worthless. 


So does science have a limit? I'm not sure. I definitely think that in many ways science should remain boundless: it encourages us to ask questions, to figure out why and not to just accept what we're told. It's empowering. But with "great power comes great responsibility" (sorry for the cheesiness). In fields like genetics, where we are dealing with the fundamentals of what makes life, we have to constantly consider consequences. I think science can limitlessly find answers, but then it has to be able to use those answers in the right way. For instance, if we ever really find out how to create life, should we actually use our knowledge to create life? We should not always feel pressured to carry out the knowledge we have discovered: sometimes it is wiser not to carry out what we know. If science can learn this wisdom, it will know where the right limits are. 


Your Genes Count: Reflection on the article "Genetics by Numbers"

Q: Collaboration in the scientific community is needed for the future of SNP research. How do you think the difficulties scientists face in trying to collaborate with one another (competition, corruption, politics, greed, pursuit of one's own interests, education etc.) can be overcome and will there be further ramifications?

A: The response to the article "Genetics by Numbers" and its presentation by Kevin has come very late (sorry!!). As to how the difficulties of collaboration in science can be overcome...first of all I want to establish that collaboration is not only necessary for development in SNP research, but is necessary for any kind of research, scientific or otherwise.So the question, although pertaining to SNPs, is really looking for a general reason for why people would share when they don't have to. And I don't think there is any simple solution to that. 

Perhaps the government could fund the institutions who conduct this research based on how much they publish their information. In other words, the more you publish and share, the more money you are eligible for. But of course this has many downsides. For instance, for companies that are privately funded, they do not need to look towards the government for money and so would not bother to publish. Also, depending on the politics of the country, not all governments would want to do this. They might want to keep their research secret. Furthermore, where will the government get all this money from? Because the government doesn't have an unlimited cash reserve, it has to be choosy on what it wants to fund, so it may not be able to fund everyone who publishes their work, which could discourage certain people to publish. 

As for solving issues like politics, maybe scientists could form a transnational group of people that are not affiliated with any one country, sort of like the United Nations. If scientists are willing to make this happen, this would transcend limits that might have been in place due to political friction, as well as bring down some competition. One of the videos we watched featured Neil deGrasse Tyson, the renowned American physicist. Although he was speaking about unity, he also said some things like, "I am first an American, and then a scientist", and that America needed to discover things before other countries did. This kind of irked me because if another country could so easily discover these things too, what does being first or second matter? It seems sort of petty. Maybe an impartial union of scientists can bring down this mindset.