Wednesday, 13 March 2013

Your Genes Count: Reflection on the article "Genetics by Numbers"

Q: Collaboration in the scientific community is needed for the future of SNP research. How do you think the difficulties scientists face in trying to collaborate with one another (competition, corruption, politics, greed, pursuit of one's own interests, education etc.) can be overcome and will there be further ramifications?

A: The response to the article "Genetics by Numbers" and its presentation by Kevin has come very late (sorry!!). As to how the difficulties of collaboration in science can be overcome...first of all I want to establish that collaboration is not only necessary for development in SNP research, but is necessary for any kind of research, scientific or otherwise.So the question, although pertaining to SNPs, is really looking for a general reason for why people would share when they don't have to. And I don't think there is any simple solution to that. 

Perhaps the government could fund the institutions who conduct this research based on how much they publish their information. In other words, the more you publish and share, the more money you are eligible for. But of course this has many downsides. For instance, for companies that are privately funded, they do not need to look towards the government for money and so would not bother to publish. Also, depending on the politics of the country, not all governments would want to do this. They might want to keep their research secret. Furthermore, where will the government get all this money from? Because the government doesn't have an unlimited cash reserve, it has to be choosy on what it wants to fund, so it may not be able to fund everyone who publishes their work, which could discourage certain people to publish. 

As for solving issues like politics, maybe scientists could form a transnational group of people that are not affiliated with any one country, sort of like the United Nations. If scientists are willing to make this happen, this would transcend limits that might have been in place due to political friction, as well as bring down some competition. One of the videos we watched featured Neil deGrasse Tyson, the renowned American physicist. Although he was speaking about unity, he also said some things like, "I am first an American, and then a scientist", and that America needed to discover things before other countries did. This kind of irked me because if another country could so easily discover these things too, what does being first or second matter? It seems sort of petty. Maybe an impartial union of scientists can bring down this mindset. 

No comments:

Post a Comment