Monday, 1 April 2013

Cancelling Cancer: Reflection on "The Cancer Genome"

(Happy April Fool's!)

Q: After the in depth discussion regarding chemotherapy, list the advantages and disadvantages of this treatment. 

A: The main advantage of chemotherapy is that when it works, it works well. If it works, it can kill cancer cells and put the patient into remission. Also, chemotherapy is one of the only widely used cancer treatment methods. 
However, chemotherapy has many disadvantages. There are many unpleasant physical side effects like fatigue, nausea, vomiting and lack of appetite. Even more serious effects, like lung, kidney, and nerve damage, are possible with prolonged use. Another symptom we all associate with chemotherapy is hair loss. However, I think it's important to not only look at hair loss as a physical effect, but also an emotional and mental effect. Hair loss because of chemotherapy makes a cancer patient feel as if the cancer has changed who they are as a person. Thus all of the pain and suffering from chemotherapy is a major disadvantage. 
(Partial source: http://www.livestrong.com/article/71774-disadvantages-chemotherapy/)




Q: Do you think that it is an effective method to "cure" cancer? Why or why not? 

A: http://www.naturalnews.com/023689_cancer_chemotherapy_patients.html claims that chemotherapy only contributed to the 5 year survival of about 2% of adults (in America and Australia). Although this is probably not the most trustworthy website, if this is true, it means that 98% of the time, chemotherapy does not contribute to a long term "cure". So either chemotherapy only buys a patient less than 5 years of additional time, or it doesn't buy a significant amount of time at all. Also, chemotherapy is essentially flushing poisons into a patient's body in the hope that they will attack the cancer. So how can we determine whether a chemotherapy patient dies from cancer or dies from the poisons used in chemotherapy? In other words, is it really chemotherapy that kills cancer patients?
I don't think anything really cures cancer: what we have at the moment are treatments, not cures. And due to our limited knowledge and our limited range of treatments for cancer, I think that chemotherapy is probably the most effective of all of them, especially if combined with other methods like surgery or radiation therapy. Which just goes to show how necessary it is to support cancer research. But in itself, I don't think chemotherapy is effective; in fact, chemo itself might be a killer. Yet it's a gamble that many people have no choice but to take. 

Q: In your opinion, under what circumstances should an individual consider chemotherapy?

A: An individual should consider chemotherapy if their tumour can easily be eliminated after the treatment, if their cancer is early-stage, or in some cases if they are young or have people who depend on them. This is because people like this have not only a higher likelihood of success, but also are more likely to be able to move on after the treatment. For young people, unless they have a severe cancer and not much time left, I think that since they have so much more to experience in life, it is more worth the risk and pain of chemotherapy. But if you have a family or friends that need you...it's difficult to say. Do you want to try and stick around for them no matter the cost to your body, or do you prefer to keep them from seeing you suffer?
If the patient is frail, elderly or in a later-stage cancer, I don't think it would be worth it to undergo chemo. It would bring about pain at a time where one should really be enjoying every moment one has. 

In general though, I think it is difficult for people to say no to chemotherapy because you know once you say no that you are signing up to die. Even though the hope that chemotherapy gives you is only 2%, it is hard to let go of that hope. Saying no to chemotherapy is kind of like giving up a fight with cancer, and that's really hard to take. All I know is that I used to think that if I was ever faced with this decision, I would say yes to chemotherapy without even thinking, because it would be the same as being asked "do you want to live or not?". But now I'm not so sure...it's not as clear cut as I thought it was. 

P.S. The Fault in Our Stars by John Green is the best book about cancer ever! Although I hate to label it as a cancer book...it's so much more. And it has the most beautiful quotes. 



No comments:

Post a Comment