Thursday, 11 April 2013

Keep This in Mind: Reflection on "Scanning Psychopath"

Q: We are afraid of psychopaths because they have no qualms about hurting other people. Discuss. 

A: This statement is quite true. Psychopaths have personality traits like ruthlessness and a lack of guilt that make them capable of doing things that other people wouldn't even be able to imagine. We cannot predict what a psychopath would do because we would be fundamentally unable to do such things. This really hit me with the example of Ed Gein. Even just typing out what he did--murdering women and taking bodies from graves and making their skin into furniture--is extremely uncomfortable and unthinkable. Another aspect of psychopaths that makes them scary is that there is no way to "cure" or treat them: it is very difficult to change the way that they think, or to instil true emotion into a person that does not actually feel anything. Furthermore, psychopaths are so manipulative and charming that a true psychopath would be very difficult to detect. This makes us feel a sort of paranoid fear because you would never know if anyone around you is a psychopath. As we heard in the presentation, even if criminal psychopaths are jailed for their crimes, their abilities to manipulate people make them more than 2.5 times more likely to receive parole than other criminals (so released criminals are more likely to have psychopathic traits). Psychopaths have very little fear themselves, and hardly get nervous. As a total, this makes psychopaths particularly scary because they have no weaknesses: they do not experience emotional attachment, they are very logical, they are masters of manipulation and they are not remorseful. Crudely put, there is no way we could "defeat" a violent psychopath. Our utter helplessness when it comes to psychopaths makes the chance that they are present around us terrifying.  
That being said, I do not want to "victimize" people with psychopathic traits, as Mr. Chung put it. Not everyone who has these traits would do these things, and as we learned in the presentation, most psychopaths are not even very violent (they would not commit violence for the sake of violence). When I read the excerpt of Professor Kevin Dutton's book Wisdom from Psychopaths?, I can see how psychopathic traits can be useful in today's world. Ruthlessness, charm and the rest can be toned down to self-preservation. One of the psychopathic patients that Dutton talks to in the excerpt jokingly puts it as having "too much of a good thing".  
In summary, I think the fact that psychopaths have the ability to do what is so morally wrong even though they know it is wrong, and that they have no weaknesses makes us very afraid of them, but we have to realize that not everyone who has some psychopathic traits can be stereotypically put into the category of criminals, and that to an extent people with psychopathic traits are beneficial and have an advantage in society. 

Sources: The article by Kevin Dutton--A MUST READ!!! http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=wisdom-from-psychopaths

No comments:

Post a Comment