Thursday, 11 April 2013

Shaken to the Core: Reflection on "Opening Up Brain Surgery"

Q: Treatment for Parkinson's disease often hinders impulse control in humans. Therefore, patients living with Parkinson's disease should not be medicated. Agree or disagree? Justify your response.

A: After doing some research on Parkinson's treatment, I think Parkinson's disease patients should be medicated even if the medication itself sometimes leads to a lack of control. This is because the lack of control for unmedicated Parkinson's patients, especially as time goes on, is much more than the occasional spasm that is a side effect of the medicine. 
Occasional gaps in control (medically known as dyskinesias) are a long-term symptom of the most commonly used Parkinson's drug: carbidopa-levodopa. Parkinson's is caused by a decrease in dopamine levels in the brain. The drug counters this by allowing the natural chemical levodopa to be converted into dopamine in the brain, a process regulated by carbidopa. Thus, the drug is the most effective option available today. 
Parkinson's disease is all about it becoming increasingly difficult to control your movement, but if the medicine can significantly lower this, then even if it lets a couple of spasms slip by, the patient will still be better off than if they had no medication. 
At least, that's what I think is meant by the term "impulse control"--not being able to command movement, since that's what I saw listed as a long-term side effect for the most common medication, carbidopa-levodopa. 
If "impulse control" means not being able to manage compulsive behaviours like eating and gambling, the culprits are drugs called dopamine agonists, not the previously mentioned carbidopa-levodopa. 
Dopamine agonists mimic dopamine, but they are not as effective as carbidopa-levodopa. To be honest, they are not used as widely as carbidopa-levodopa, instead being used in combination with carbidopa-levodopa for a longer-lasting effect. 
So first of all I don't think they would have a very great affect on control of compulsive behaviours, because they are simply not used as much. However, does control of compulsive behaviour really affect the patients that much? From the video we watched, the surprisingly young lady who suffered from Parkinson's disease was most disheartened because she could no longer control little things that we take for granted, like being able to wield a mascara wand with accuracy. 
I do not know if she was unable to put on mascara despite her medication, but I feel if medication could help her do that small task even a little bit better, then she would be a lot more happy and hopeful. To me it seems that the little things impacted the patients more than issues like eating or gambling. 
Either way, I think it is worth it to take these medication despite its side effects because the flip side is so much worse. These drugs will restore at least some control in your life, affecting you not only physically but mentally and emotionally as well. These medications, if they allow the patient to feel less like their disease is literally taking over their life, should be used. 

Sources: http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/parkinsons-disease/DS00295/DSECTION=treatments-and-drugs , http://www.pdf.org/en/parkinson_prescription_meds

No comments:

Post a Comment